William Saunders’ Capital Punishment.

Use the comments, highlights, etc. features to annotate this excerpt from William Saunders’ Capital Punishment.


Note: You may also print it out and annotate it that way if you wish.


Capital Punishment

By William Saunders


The issue of capital punishment is indeed a highly debated issue in our country. For Catholics, the issue is more problematic because of the Church’s teaching regarding the sanctity of human life and the dignity of the person, which seems to oppose the use of capital punishment.


The Catechism does state, “Preserving the common good of society requires rendering the aggressor unable to inflict harm. For this reason, the traditional teaching of the Church has acknowledged as well-founded the right and duty of legitimate public authority to punish

malefactors by means of penalties commensurate with the gravity of the crime not excluding, in cases of extreme gravity, the death penalty” (No.2266). To understand the Church’s position in this matter, we have to be clear about the foundational principles governing the teaching.


First, the state has the duty to preserve the common good and to protect its citizens from harm. Therefore, the state may declare and wage a just war against an aggressor outside of the community as well as recognize the individual’s legal right of self-defense. A state may also impose just penalties on those individuals who commit crimes and threaten the well- being of society.


Second, justice demands that punishment fit the crime; the penalty must be proportionate to the injury. In this way, punishment provides for proper retribution, deterrence and deform. As a form of retribution, punishment restores the order of justice which the criminal violated. For example, if a criminal steals something, restitution must be made, such as the return of the stolen property. The criminal may also be deprived of certain freedoms through, for instance, incarceration or fines. Just retribution attempts to heal the injury caused by the crime.


Just retribution, however, is not vengeance. After the guilty verdict for Timothy McVeigh, a local Denver radio station set-up a stand near the federal courthouse and enticed drivers to honk if they wanted to “fry” him. True justice mandates that we eliminate vengeance.


Along this line of thought, punishment ought to deter future crime. If justice is rendered fairly and swiftly, specific punishment for specific crimes ought to prevent further crime by either the criminal himself or others. Punishment should not only protect society from a particular criminal but also deter individuals from committing the same crime in the future.


In the end, the punishment of a criminal should incite his reform. The criminal being punished is hopefully moved to see the error of his ways, to repent and to change his life.


Just punishment strives to balance all three perspectives; retribution, deterrence and reform. Note also that in applying such punishment the state must ensure to the best of its ability that the person receives a fair trial and that only a legitimate authority impose any sentence.


Following this perspective of punishment, capital punishment may be used only for heinous crimes, crimes which shake the foundations of society and which would necessitate such a severe proportionate punishment For example, the Old Testament laws permitted the use of capital punishment for serious sins: “If anyone sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed; for in the image of God has man been made” (Gn 9:6) and “Whoever strikes a man a mortal blow must be put to death. When a man kills another after maliciously scheming to do so, you must take him even from my altar and put him to death” (Ex 21:12, 14). However, capital crimes in the Old Testament included not just premeditated murder, but also kidnapping, cursing or striking of parents, sorcery, sodomy, bestiality and idolatry. These sins were so heinous in the eyes of God and so threatening to the spiritual and physical welfare of the community that justice mandated capital punishment as proper retribution.


The capital sentence could inspire reform. The condemned criminal facing the loss of his life and knowing he will appear before God in judgment, would hopefully repent.


The capital sentence could also deter future crime. Removed from society permanently and sent to God for divine justice, the criminal would never inflict injury again. St. Thomas Aquinas affirmed that if the good citizens “are protected and saved by the slaying of the wicked, then the latter may be lawfully put to death.” Moreover, the execution of a criminal should also deter others from committing like crimes and inspire their reform.


Please keep in mind that the Old Testament does speak of God’s divine mercy: “As I live says the Lord God, I swear I take no pleasure in the death of the

wicked man, but rather in the wicked man’s conversion, that he may live” (Ez 33:11). “That he may live” may not so much focus on physical life as it does on the spiritual life, whereby the repentant sinner would avoid eternal punishment in hell.


Finally, capital punishment may be used to punish “malefactors,” i.e. people who freely choose to commit a heinous crime. St. Thomas Aquinas asserted that through sin, a man departs from the order of reason and falls away from the dignity of being an individual made in God’s image and likeness. A man who commits a heinous crime, he argued, is even worse than a brute beast and even more harmful. Such a man may be permanently extricated: Just as an infectious or diseased organ would be removed to preserve the health of the entire body, so a person who is dangerous or infectious to the community may be executed rather than corrupt or bring harm to the community.


Such a malefactor must be distinguished from an innocent person. Human life is indeed sacred in all forms and all times, and we as innocent human beings have a sacred right to life. However, the Church carefully underscores the inviolability of this right for “innocent life.” In the “Declaration on Euthanasia” (1980) the Church asserted, “Nothing and no one can in any way permit the killing of an innocent human being, whether a fetus or an embryo, an infant or an adult, an old person or one suffering from an incurable disease, or a person who is dying,” and in the “Declaration on Procured Abortion” (1974) the Church asserted “Divine law and natural reason, therefore, exclude all right to the direct killing of an innocent man.” Pope John Paul II in his recent encyclical Evangelium Vitae confirmed…the direct and voluntary killing of an innocent human being, always gravely immoral” (No. 57). When a person freely commits such a heinous crime and is judged as a threat to society as a whole, that person relinquishes the right to life in this society, this time and this space.


Given this reasoning, the Catholic Church has in principle upheld the right of the state to execute certain criminals.

Academic Heros
Calculate your paper price
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Work with Us

Top Quality and Well-Researched Papers

Our writers are encouraged to read and research widely to have rich information before writing clients’ papers. Therefore, be it high school or PhD level paper, it will always be a well-researched work handled by experts.

Professional and Experienced Academic Writers

For one to become part of our team, thorough interview and vetting is undertaken to make sure their academic level and experience are beyond reproach, hence enabling us give our clients top quality work.

Free Unlimited Revisions

Once you have received your paper and feel that some issues have been missed, just request for revision and it will be done. In addition, you can present your work to the tutor and he/she asks for improvement/changes, we are always ready to assist.

Prompt Delivery and 100% Money-Back-Guarantee

All our papers are sent to the clients before the deadline to allow them time to review the work before presenting to the tutor. If for some reason we feel our writers cannot meet the deadline, we will contact you to ask for more time. If this is not possible, then the paid amount will be refunded.

Original & Confidential

Our writers have been trained to ensure work produced is free of plagiarism. Software to check originality are also applied. Our clients’ information is highly guarded from third parties to ensure confidentiality is maintained.

24/7 Customer Support

Our support team is available 24 hours, 7 days a week. You can reach the team via live chat, email or phone call. You can always get in touch whenever you need any assistance.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

You have had a hectic day, and still need to complete your assignment, yet it is late at night. No need to panic. Place your order with us, retire to bed, and once you wake up, the paper will be ready.


Essay Writing Service

It does not matter the urgency of your paper, or the academic level, our team is ready to help you 24/7. Just contact us and all your academic needs will be sorted.


Admission Essays & Business Writing Help

A student is often required to write an admission letter requesting to be admitted in a certain institution. For you to be gain that admission in your dream institution, you must write a convincing letter. You can depend on our team for the best admission letters.


Editing Support

Academic writing is not just about getting information and throwing it all over. Our team will ensure you have a polished paper that is coherent and has a good flow of information. We also ensure the paper follows the correct formatting styles like APA, Harvard, MLA, Chicago/Turabian.


Revision Support

If our writers write a paper but you are not satisfied in one way or another, you can always ask for revision. This is totally free. Our writers and editors will revise your paper untill you are be totally satisfied. We as well offer revision for papers not done by our writers at a small fee.